[SURBL-Discuss] RFC: Public false positve reporting form

Jeff Chan jeffc at surbl.org
Fri Sep 3 16:31:34 CEST 2004

On Monday, August 30, 2004, 5:57:53 AM, Rob McEwen wrote:
> The quicker TTLs is helping with the savy spammers. Also, I recall something
> about a newer version of SURBL which will use some kind of tracking to trace
> new domains back to older ones in order to attributing new spam to known and
> confirmed spammers so that they would stay "attached" to their previous bad
> records in order to blacklist them faster. What ever became of this? (Did I
> explain this correctly?)

Yes, it's on my list of things to do.  I will get to it
eventually and the new system could be a basis for
generalized spam domain feed handling. Where there is
a real time feed of spam domains, as from SpamCop or
perhaps good spamtraps, the reports can like be a
voting system where more reports means more likely

Basing this on human reports, as from SpamCop, is
probably best since automation usually leads to too
many FPs.

The idea is to take the top N percentile (probably 85th
percentile) of reports, thus hopefully leaving behind the
FPs in the low-level "noisy" bottom 15th percentile.

In addition the IP address of the domain will be resolved
and "remembered".  Future domains that resolve to the same
IPs will probably inherit the report counts of the whole
IP range or some fraction thereof.  That will catch
spammers whose web sites are on the same IPs or range
of IPs.

By the way we have lowered the TTLs on the lists to
1 hour, then 25 minutes, now 20 minutes.  We may try
15 minutes also.  We will pick the TTL that minimizes
both DNS traffic and TTL.  (At some TTL point the DNS
traffic will ramp up significantly; from which we will
back off one time period.  We already know it's quite a bit
higher at 10 minutes, but not much higher at 20 minutes,
so that point is somewhere in between.)   We are using
real world testing to find the optimum TTL for our type
of data and application.

Jeff C.

More information about the Discuss mailing list